Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Harris's avatar

Good stuff. As far as our default state, if given a scale, almost everyone will report their happiness or contentment in the upper half. That people do this to me is kind of strange to me, but to some, it is entirely natural. I was in a personality/social psychology grad program where happiness was one of the faculty's areas of study, and I remember one of my fellow students telling me that if you didn't report your happiness as at least 5 on a 1-10 scale, you must be clinically depressed. Later, for one of my classes, we did inventories anonymously to create a dataset, and indeed, everyone except me did say they were very happy. I think there is some truth to the idea that to be healthy is to be happy, and to be healthy (and alive) is the default state. To live is a gift but also a daily choice, which we say "yes" to....(here I ape a Viktor Frankl title).

You've intrigued me about that Kafka exhibit, and I appreciated the detail you provided there. Reminds me of an exhibit I went to in the city on Salinger a few years ago (New York Public Library 2019?), and he also came across as lovely, magnanimous, and funny. I know all about self presentation and public relations, but at the very least, he had loyal friends who were willing to protect him, and there's a lot to be said for that. To me, it's not about whether these writers were good people or bad people, but really just about trying to understand them. I think of your blog from a few weeks ago, about where the artist places themselves in their work, and what they say in the business of introducing it. About whether we want to see the writer at all, or whether we want to look away.

Expand full comment
Patty Dann's avatar

yes, to flowers and good neighbors!

Expand full comment

No posts